Arbella Mutual Insurance Company

For your convenience, the following options are available for paying your premiums:
Questions about Your Bill?
You can call the Arbella billing department directly at 800-972-5348 (press 1 then 2) or contact us during normal business hours and we'll be happy to help!
Pay by Postal Mail
Arbella Mutual Insurance Company
PO Box 55392
Boston, MA 02205-5392
Overnight Mail
Arbella Mutual Insurance Company
1100 Crown Colony Drive
Quincy, MA 02169-0934
Pay Online
Click here to pay by check, credit or debit card.  ($3.50 fee applies)
Pay by Phone
Call 617-328-2666 to make a one-time payment by check, credit or debit card.  ($3.50 fee applies)
Sign Up for EFT
Click here to enroll in the Automated Payment Plan so that payments will automatically be deducted from your checking or savings account on a recurring basis.  This service is only available for Massachusetts personal auto and homeowner policies.